American Gothic (1995)

Trinity, South Carolina hides dark secrets beneath its surface. Sheriff Lucas Buck becomes obsessively fixated on young Caleb, who is caught in a web of danger. Caleb's cousin, Gail, finds herself torn between her desire to shield him and her complicated feelings for Buck. Adding to the tension, Caleb's deceased sister Merlyn reappears as a celestial figure, delivering dire warnings about Buck's true nature—suggesting he may embody pure malevolence and might not even be human. As loyalties clash, the battle between good and evil intensifies in this gripping supernatural drama.