My Two Dads (1987)

Joey and Michael, rivals from 13 years past, find themselves unexpectedly united after the death of the woman they both loved. With joint custody of her daughter, Nicole, who could belong to either man, they forego the usual paternity test. Instead, they decide to cohabitate and create a unique two-dad family dynamic. Navigating the challenges of parenthood under the scrutiny of a family court judge, the trio embarks on a humorous journey of adjustment, exploring the complexities of their unconventional arrangement while forging a bond that transcends traditional family roles.